Rip up 'immoral' aid rules to help Hurricane Irma victims, say ministers amid fury at restrictions on cash for islands deemed 'too rich'

  • Pot of £13billion aid cannot be used because British territories are 'too wealthy'
  • It means that rescue funding will have to come from other Government budgets
  • The cost of rescuing the British Overseas Territories could stretch to £100m 

Theresa May (pictured in Downing Street yesterday) is 'frustrated' at foreign aid rules preventing Britain from using its £13billion aid budget on help islands devastated by Hurricane Irma

Theresa May (pictured in Downing Street yesterday) is 'frustrated' at foreign aid rules preventing Britain from using its £13billion aid budget on help islands devastated by Hurricane Irma

Ministers were last night frantically trying to change rules that prevent Britain from spending its aid budget to help UK territories hit by Hurricane Irma.

International Development Secretary Priti Patel fired off a letter to the global body which ruled that the UK cannot use its aid cash because the three overseas territories are too wealthy.

She wrote to the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development to demand reforms to end the farce.

But other ministers said she should go ahead anyway and use the aid budget to help the victims of Irma even if that means breaking the law.

A senior Tory source said: ‘It’s a waste of time asking the OECD to change its mind. We’ve been asking them to change this stupid definition for years and they are not interested. We should just get on and do it ourselves.’

He added: ‘Our law says we have got to spend 0.7 per cent on aid, which is good, but it also says we have to spend it according to a ridiculous definition, which is bad. 

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, who has just returned from a trip to see the devastation in the Caribbean, told a press conference it was 'natural' that the money should be used to help those affected

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson, who has just returned from a trip to see the devastation in the Caribbean, told a press conference it was 'natural' that the money should be used to help those affected

'The rules do not allow development spending on these islands because they are not considered poor enough. It is immoral and a lot of people are saying we should just ignore the rules and spend the money.’

Charlotte Petri Gornitzka, who chairs the OECD’s development assistance committee (DAC), suggested the door was open to change.

‘The DAC is always open to discussing issues of concern with its member countries,’ she said.

Why cash goes... a pop group and flatulent cows

£4million to fund Ethiopia’s own Spice Girls. Yegna launched a radio show and videos to empower women in the African country.

£15million on a scheme to reduce the flatulence of Colombian cattle to fight climate change.

£25million to team up meteorologists with Kenyan ‘rain-makers’ who observe the movement of ants to predict the weather.

Britain committed £700million to help impoverished children in Pakistan – where corrupt officials creamed off vast amounts of cash.

£3million on unwanted helicopters to help out with the aftermath of the Nepal earthquake.

A £22.5million programme of aid for China included role-play sessions to encourage young people there to think about climate change.

£1.8million to build a hotel and leisure complex in Barbados which will train 200 young people a year in ‘hospitality management’.

Britain gives £72million a year to Palestine, more than one-third of which goes straight to the Palestinian Authority, which critics say supports terrorists.

A report from an aid watchdog found that UK aid fuels corruption in Nigeria.

Advertisement

Downing Street made clear yesterday that Theresa May is ‘frustrated’ with the OECD rules which exclude British overseas territories like Anguilla, the Turks and Caicos islands and the British Virgin Islands from receiving money from the aid pot.

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson said Whitehall was working furiously to get the rules changed.

As MPs’ anger grew, one branded the OECD ‘out-of-touch morons’ while a Tory backbencher pledged to introduce a bill to change the law, whether or not the OECD gives the green light.

Miss Patel’s letter to the DAC yesterday called for the current rules to be torn up.

She said she had asked the committee ‘as a matter of urgency to develop options to ensure the aid rules reflect the needs of those impacted by natural disasters’.

She added: ‘We believe that the international rules should take into account the vulnerabilities of small island states.

‘These rules were first established over 40 years ago. The world has changed dramatically since then, and we will work constructively with international partners to ensure the rules remain relevant and up to date.’

The UK has pledged £57million towards disaster relief and the public has helped to raise around £1.3million.

But an unnamed minister told the BBC the figure would have been significantly higher without the strict international rules governing the allocation of the £13billion aid budget – a claim disputed by Downing Street.

Mrs May’s official spokesman insisted the UK’s aid effort had not been hampered by the OECD rules. He added: ‘The Prime Minister is frustrated with the rules as they stand. We began detailed work after the election to change the rules to prevent precisely these kinds of scenarios.’

Ruins: The scale of the hurricane's power can be seen in this aerial picture of a town in the British Virgin Islands

Ruins: The scale of the hurricane's power can be seen in this aerial picture of a town in the British Virgin Islands

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson visited the islands yesterday to meet survivors and survey the damage. He flew out after French president Emmanuel Macron and the Dutch king visited their citizens in the region 

Foreign Secretary Boris Johnson visited the islands yesterday to meet survivors and survey the damage. He flew out after French president Emmanuel Macron and the Dutch king visited their citizens in the region 

British relief efforts have been criticised as ¿absolutely pathetic¿ in comparison with those of France and the Netherlands. Mr Johnson promised more cash 

British relief efforts have been criticised as 'absolutely pathetic' in comparison with those of France and the Netherlands. Mr Johnson promised more cash 

He indicated the UK could be prepared to act alone if there was no agreement on changing the international rules.

Mr Johnson said the hurricane was ‘absolutely catastrophic’ and that anybody with an ‘ounce of compassion’ would want to see government spending to ‘get these people on their feet’.

‘We are looking now across Whitehall at ways we can make sure that our aid budget is used in that way,’ he said. ‘Priti Patel, all my colleagues are looking at how we can do that.’

James Duddridge, a former Foreign Office minister and now member of the Commons international development committee, said he would introduce a ten-minute rule bill to rewrite the law on the 0.7 per cent target.

British relief efforts have been criticised as ¿absolutely pathetic¿ in comparison with those of France and the Netherlands. But Mr Johnson has promised more cash. Pictured: A Royal Marine hands out water in Road Town, British Virgin Islands 

British relief efforts have been criticised as 'absolutely pathetic' in comparison with those of France and the Netherlands. But Mr Johnson has promised more cash. Pictured: A Royal Marine hands out water in Road Town, British Virgin Islands 

Hurricane Irma left Anguilla devastated, with swathes of the island left uninhabitable 

Hurricane Irma left Anguilla devastated, with swathes of the island left uninhabitable 

Images, provided by the NASA Earth Observatory, shows Caribbean islands looking a vibrant green (top), while a second - captured after the hurricane (bottom) - shows the territory is coloured brown. The islands, from left, are St. Thomas, St. John, Tortola and Virgin Gorda

Images, provided by the NASA Earth Observatory, shows Caribbean islands looking a vibrant green (top), while a second - captured after the hurricane (bottom) - shows the territory is coloured brown. The islands, from left, are St. Thomas, St. John, Tortola and Virgin Gorda

The foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, talks to residents on the British Virgin Islands after Irma hit the Caribbean 

The foreign secretary, Boris Johnson, talks to residents on the British Virgin Islands after Irma hit the Caribbean 

Why we can't spent it how we want

Britain is free to spend its aid wherever it wants – what is at issue is whether it counts towards the Government’s 0.7 per cent target.

Last year, the UK spent £13billion on aid, money which went towards the target to spend 0.7 per cent of national income on international development. But aid money only counts towards the target if it meets rules set by the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development.

So under current rules, any money we give to the three overseas territories cannot count towards this total. Cash is only eligible if it goes towards a country on the OECD’s list of states which are deemed poor enough.

Countries are ranked according to need, which is intended to ensure the poorest countries take priority. While some UK territories are on this list, the three affected by Irma are not.

Britain has sent £57million to Turks and Caicos, Anguilla and the British Virgin Islands. But it cannot count towards ‘official development assistance’, the name for the total eligible under the rules. 

Advertisement
Devastation: Boris surveys the massive amount of damage done to the Caribbean island of Anguilla during the Category 5 Hurricane Irma 

Devastation: Boris surveys the massive amount of damage done to the Caribbean island of Anguilla during the Category 5 Hurricane Irma 

Villages on Providenciales (pictured) in the Turks and Caicos islands were devastated by the force to Hurricane Irma

Villages on Providenciales (pictured) in the Turks and Caicos islands were devastated by the force to Hurricane Irma

‘The Government should change development assistance rules, and if they don’t, they bring forward legislation to change the International Development Act,’ he said.

‘If they don’t, I will bring a bill to Parliament to redefine what our excellent 0.7 per cent commitment should cover.’

His colleague Philip Davies, who called the OECD ‘out-of-touch morons’, told the Commons: ‘It’s bad enough that we have a bloated and wasteful and unaffordable overseas aid budget but it’s even more ridiculous that we now learn that we cannot spend it on our overseas territories.’

Fellow Tory Nigel Evans said: ‘These rules are grotesque if they prevent us from giving the right amount of money that is needed. If we can’t bend the rules then we have to go outside those rules.’  

A picture provided by the British Ministry of Defence  shows cars that have been turned to wrecks by Hurricane Irma on the British Virgin Islands

A picture provided by the British Ministry of Defence shows cars that have been turned to wrecks by Hurricane Irma on the British Virgin Islands

A Royal Air Force C-130J Hercules transport aircraft touches down on the Turks and Caicos Islands to deliver aid after the Overseas Territory was battered by Hurricanes Irma and Jose 

A Royal Air Force C-130J Hercules transport aircraft touches down on the Turks and Caicos Islands to deliver aid after the Overseas Territory was battered by Hurricanes Irma and Jose 

A C-17 aircraft at Grantley Adams International Airport in Bridgetown, Barbados, sent by the British Government to deliver aid to the Caribbean in the wake of the devastating storms 

A C-17 aircraft at Grantley Adams International Airport in Bridgetown, Barbados, sent by the British Government to deliver aid to the Caribbean in the wake of the devastating storms 

Royal Marines from from 59 Commando Squadron have been tasked with helping to clean up Tortola in the British Virgin Islands after the area was destroyed by Hurricane Irma
Royal Marines from from 59 Commando Squadron have been tasked with helping to clean up Tortola in the British Virgin Islands after the area was destroyed by Hurricane Irma

Royal Marines from from 59 Commando Squadron have been tasked with helping to clean up Tortola in the British Virgin Islands after the area was destroyed by Hurricane Irma

Luxury yachts are still piled on top of each other in marinas in Road Town, on Tortola - part of the British Virgin Islands. There have been reports of looting in the area

Luxury yachts are still piled on top of each other in marinas in Road Town, on Tortola - part of the British Virgin Islands. There have been reports of looting in the area

An aerial photograph of the Turks and Caicos islands taken by a Royal Air Force C-130J Hercules transport plane 

An aerial photograph of the Turks and Caicos islands taken by a Royal Air Force C-130J Hercules transport plane 

Soldiers on patrol in Road Town meet locals after the devastation of Hurricane Irma 

Soldiers on patrol in Road Town meet locals after the devastation of Hurricane Irma 

Tory MP Philip Davies blasted the news Britain cannot use its foreign aid budget on the territories. He said: ¿It is absolutely ridiculous that we cannot use any of our bloated overseas aid budget to help British overseas territories devastated by the hurricane'. Pictured: A Royal Marine speaking with a local on the British Virgin Islands 

Tory MP Philip Davies blasted the news Britain cannot use its foreign aid budget on the territories. He said: 'It is absolutely ridiculous that we cannot use any of our bloated overseas aid budget to help British overseas territories devastated by the hurricane'. Pictured: A Royal Marine speaking with a local on the British Virgin Islands 

Royal Air Force logisticians from RAF Brize Norton have assisted with the delivery of military personnel and aid cargo. Pictured: Supplies being unloaded from a plane in Barbados 

Royal Air Force logisticians from RAF Brize Norton have assisted with the delivery of military personnel and aid cargo. Pictured: Supplies being unloaded from a plane in Barbados 

Boris spoke with locals in Anguilla after their island was devastated by Hurricane Irma last week 

Boris spoke with locals in Anguilla after their island was devastated by Hurricane Irma last week 

The comments below have not been moderated.

The views expressed in the contents above are those of our users and do not necessarily reflect the views of MailOnline.

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.